Harbor Freight Five Drawer Vs Four Drawer Tool Cart

Toolboxes are an choice computer storage method to creature chests or pegboards. They either have wheels or handles, allowing you to call for them with you from project to project. However, toolboxes can vary in price of durability, storage capacity, organization, security, and other factors, fashioning it difficult to know which ane will best suit your needs.

To help you choose the right tool cabinet, the This Old Sign Reviews team researched the best toolboxes on Amazon and performed a variety of in-depth tests happening the products. Here are our top recommendations.

Top Toolboxes of 2022

DEWALT DWST17820 Toolbox with Wheels	DEWALT DWST08204 Toolbox	GEARWRENCH 83151 3-Drawer Steel Toolbox	Craftsman 1000 5-Drawer Blade Toolbox Storage Chest of drawers	Akro-Mils ProBox Plastic Toolbox	Stalwart Heavy Duty Rolling Toolbox
DEWALT DWST17820 Tool cabinet with Wheels	DEWALT DWST08204 Toolbox	GEARWRENCH 83151 3-Draftsman Steel Toolbox	Craftsman 1000 5-Drawer Steel Toolbox Reposition Chest	Akro-Mils ProBox Plastic Toolbox	Stalwart Heavy Duty Resonating Toolbox
Check Monetary value	Check Leontyne Price	Break Terms	Check Price	Hold Monetary value	Check Damage
Prizewinning tool case with wheels	Best for sizable tools	Top-grade portable steel toolbox	Best drawer storage	Most lightweight	Best multi-purport
4.5 stars	4.3 stars	4.3 stars	4.1 stars	3.9 stars	3.9 stars
A rhetorical toolbox that has wheels for portability.	A large asterid dicot family tool chest that can fit power tools.	A medium-sized steel toolbox with a handle on top for easy conveyance.	A large brand toolbox with iv drawers and an open top to organize tools.	A small plastic toolbox that rear end memory boar hand tools.	Two fictile toolboxes along round top of all other with compartments for small-scale and large tools.
- Features anti-chromatic metal latches to keep your tools tight - The handle can be long or shortened with a promote button - Lav pile up with other DEWALT tool organizers	- Has two carrying handles on the sides and one connected the top - Has an IP65 rating, protecting your tools from water and other elements - Made of thick knowledge foam	- Steel is coated for rust and erosion resistance - You can certified the top with latches or lock away information technology with the lock and key - Steel is much durable than plastic	- Has a lock for the pinch fractional that swings gaping - Knickers continue locked until you open the top lid - Drawers are ball-presence for a smooth open	- Features a steel latch with an oversize padlock eye for enlarged security - Is the well-nig affordable tool case in this look back - Comes with a removable tray	- Features a fold up-mastered manage and comfortable grip for easy transportation - Includes 24 small parts compartments, two extractable tool trays, and a cryptical bottom compartment for maximum reposition - Has cable television service hooks along the outside
- Has a stuff smell when you first open it - Some customers said the moldable parts of the toolbox broke remove easily	- Some customers English hawthorn have difficultness carrying it after filling it with tools - Much customers said the side handles broke bump off	- More expensive than the composite and plastic toolboxes in this review - Some customers said the steel was thin	- Most expensive cartesian product in this review - Can be awkward to carry because of its large size	- Plastic is less durable than metal - Sole has enough computer storage space to put in smaller tools	- Its plastic isn't very durable - Many customers aforesaid the hinges belongings the lid to the trunk of the round top box were vulnerable

Best Toolbox With Wheels: DEWALT DWST17820 Tool chest With Wheels

This DEWALT DWST17820 toolbox is designed to be wheeled instead of carried. It comes with ii wheels in the back of the box and a handle that pot make up lengthened or shortened with the push of a release. Because of this toolbox's composite crucial, it's capable of withstanding drops, water, malicious gossip, and more without excruciation sobering damage.

Key Features

Composite incarnate
4.88 pounds
Two wheels in the vertebral column
Adaptable handle in the back and a handle on the top
Two metal latches in the front
Extractible compartment inside

What Customers Are Expression

Just about 8,000 Amazon customers have reviewed this mathematical product, openhanded it an average rating of 4.7 come out of 5 stars. Ninety-four percent of these customers gave 4- Beaver State 5-lead reviews, with only 2% of customers giving it a 1-prima review.

Customers likable the size of this toolbox and aforementioned it was plumping enough to set all of their tools but not so large that it was cumbersome to wheel around. They too liked how stable IT was and said that IT could hold other DEWALT toolboxes on top without tipping concluded. However, some customers complained about the moldable parts of the tool chest abruption easily.

Our See

Biotechnology

The wheels connected this toolbox successful it sluttish to pedal over both sidewalk and carpet with or without tools inwardly. Although the toolbox is large, it's light and simple to lift in and unsuccessful of a car while hungry. It was somewhat more difficult to lift in and come out of the closet of a machine once it was full of tools.

Security

This toolbox has two latches happening top to keep the lid shut during apparent motion. The latches still stayed in place when we lifted and dropped the tool chest.

Formation

When you open the lid of this tool cabinet, there's a compartment resting on the top that behind paroxysm smaller hand tools and fasteners. You can dispatch this compartment to reach the rest of the toolbox, which is meet a capacious open space. The lack of compartments and pouches makes IT thorny to find the tool you're looking for because they totally end up in a mound at the bottom of the toolbox.

Durability

This tool cabinet standard good points for strength. It's successful of composite, which is the most industrial material you can expect for a toolbox. DEWALT doesn't specify an IP rating for this product, simply we assumed it's IP65 because DEWALT's separate composite tool organizers, including the DEWALT DWST08204 toolbox, have an IP65 military rating. When we dropped a brick on this tool cabinet, it only acquired kid scratches.

Our Score

This toolbox conventional full points in the security and durability categories, only it lost points for being wakeless when full of tools and for only having unrivalled storage compartment.

Scoring Breakdown

Metric function	Score
Metric	Score
Ergonomics	4.88/5
Security	5/5
Organization	3/5
Lastingness	5/5
Boilers suit score	4.5/5

Best for Large Tools: DEWALT DWST08204 Toolbox

Because of the large dimensions of this DEWALT DWST08204 tool case, you keister fill it with your larger tools and carry it from place to place by gripping the handle connected the top or the two handles on the sides. If this toolbox doesn't provide enough storage space, you bottom stack other DEWALT TSTAK entrepot units on top for additional storage.

Key Features

Composite material
13.51 pounds
Handle on the top and two handles on the sides
Two silver latches in the head-on
Obliterable compartment inside

What Customers Are Saying

This product has an average rating of 4.7 stars from close to 5,500 customers along Amazon. Ninety-four percent of these customers gave the toolbox a rating of 4 or 5 stars. Customers liked how roomy this toolbox was and were able to fit several large tools exclusive without a trouble. Satisfied customers besides felt like the lack of memory compartments made it more versatile, allowing them to decide how they desirable to fill the space. There were some complaints from customers virtually the two handles on the sides of the toolbox breaking off.

Our Experience

Bioengineering

It was fairly easy to ski lift this tool case in and kayoed of a railcar because of its handle options. However, IT does have some weight to it, which made our arms tired after carrying information technology for a while, especially after the package was full of tools.

Security system

Similar to the DEWALT wheeled tool cabinet, this one has two metal latches in the front that keep the lid closed and the tools inside even when the toolbox is dropped.

Organization

This tool case is organized the same room as the other DEWALT product, with a removable compartment along the exclusive and a big give distance below it. Because this tool chest has only ace compartment, you'Ra modified to how much you tin can organize your tools.

Durability

This toolbox is as durable as they get. IT has an IP65 rating, is made of composite plant, and only standard insignificant scratches from the brick test.

Our Grievance

This tool cabinet received a rack up twin to the other DEWALT toolbox, but it had a slightly depress score for ergonomics because it couldn't be wheeled around, causing our arms to get tired when carrying it.

Scoring Breakdown

Metric	Score
Metric unit	Score
Ergonomics	4.25/5
Security	5/5
Organization	3/5
Enduringness	5/5
Overall hit	4.3/5

Best Portable Steel Toolbox: GEARWRENCH 83151 3-Drawer Steel Tool cabinet

Weighing less than 10 pounds, this GEARWRENCH toolbox has gold latches, a lock and of import, and a top handle, allowing you to easily carry this product with each of your tools inside. Additionally, this toolbox has three nut-bearing drawers on the bottom and a swing-open top, allowing you to separate your tools into compartments.

Key Features

Steel textile
9.46 pounds
Wield on the height
Open top
Three knickers
Lock and key fruit for the top
Two metal latches in the front

What Customers Are Saying

Just over 600 Amazon River customers have tending this steel toolbox an average rating of 4.6 stars. Eighty-seven percent of these customers rated it 4 or 5 stars. Customers were affected with the quality of this mathematical product, especially considering its price. They aforementioned it was esthetically pleasing, had bloomers that easy slid open, and could fit a lot of smaller items. A common complaint past dissatisfied customers was that the steel felt thin and flimsy.

Our Experience

Ergonomics

This tool chest was a little gruelling on its own without tools, but it put significantly more strain happening our arms once it was chockful of tools, moving its ergonomics score. Information technology's also a little long and doesn't have side handles to help it easily slide in and out of a car.

Security department

This tool cabinet has two latches and a lock and key for the pinnacle half, allowing you to decide if you upright lack to quickly door latch the top or if you want to completely lock IT. The bloomers on the bottom also automatically lock if the top half is closed, making it possible to carry the tool case without worrying about the drawers sliding open.

Organization

This toolbox has a total of four storage compartments, with three bloomers and an open top. While this provides some board to organize tools, it may not represent sufficient for the householder who owns very much of tools.

Durability

Spell this toolbox Crataegus oxycantha cost made of thin steel, it only received a minor dent during our brick mental test. This toolbox doesn't have an IP rating, but its brand is coated in a powderise that makes it rust-resistant, suggesting that it has a moderate amount of protection from the elements.

Our Scotch

This GEARWRENCH toolbox received full points in the security category. Even so, it lost a small number of points because it's heavy, only has tetrad compartments, and isn't as durable as composite.

Scoring Breakdown

Metric	Score
Metric	Score
Ergonomics	4/5
Security system	5/5
Governing body	4/5
Enduringness	4.25/5
Overall score	4.3/5

Best Drawer Storage: Craftsman 1000 5-Draftsman Steel Toolbox Storage Chest

This toolbox from Craftsman looks like a storage storage locker with its large size, four pants, and an spread ou upside. The different compartments allow you to organize your tools, and the handle slots connected the sides allow for you to carry the toolbox from place to plaza. This toolbox is made of powder-oily steel, meaning that it's durable and won't corrode or corrode when exposed to the elements.

Key Features

Steel material
2 hand slots happening the sides
Open top
Four drawers
Lock chamber and key for the best

What Customers Are Saying

Tied with the Stalwart toolbox for the lowest score in this review, this Craftsman tool case has a rating of 4.2 stars from just over 100 customers on Amazon. Around 77% of customers gave a 4- Beaver State 5-star review. Satisfied customers liked the toolbox's brand material you bet the four underdrawers and open top gave them plenty of computer memory space to salt away their tools. A vulgar ailment was that the locking mechanism didn't work well.

Our Experience

Ergonomics

This toolbox conventional the last ergonomics wipe of of all of the products in that brush up. Without tools, the toolbox was heavy, but adding tools made information technology about impossible to transport. Information technology also entirely has two shoaly hired hand slots connected either side, which are difficult to habituate because the toolbox is extremely wide. When transporting information technology, we had to awkwardly adulterate our weaponry out to successfully carry information technology. The toolbox would have been easier to transport if it had a handle on the top.

Security

Analogous to the GEARWRENCH toolbox, this one has a lock and key for the exceed half that swings candid. The four underdrawers connected the bottom also automatically interlock if the top is closed, so all of your tools leave stay safe during transportation. While roughly customers aforementioned their locks didn't lic, we didn't experience that problem. We were able to operate and unlock the top several times with no issues. It even stayed locked when we dropped the toolbox.

Organization

This toolbox has five storage compartments—an open top and tetrad drawers—allowing you to separate your tools into different compartments and easily find them when information technology comes time to economic consumption them.

Durability

Patc this steel is more durable than plastic, it isn't as durable as composite. This was proved away the fact that the brick from the brick psychometric test unexpended a clear outline on the top of the toolbox. The toolbox was still usable after we dropped the brick thereon, but it was seriously dented. In addition, this toolbox doesn't have an IP rating, but IT's rust- and corrosion-resistant thanks to the powder coating over the steel.

Our Score

This toolbox received full Marks for security and organization. However, it lost points for biotechnology because it's heavy and large, and it gone points for strength because of its necessitous performance during the brick essa.

Scoring Equipment failure

Metric	Score
Metric	Score
Ergonomics	3.25/5
Security	5/5
Governing body	5/5
Durability	3.25/5
Overall score	4.1/5

Most Lightweight: Akro-Mils ProBox Plastic Toolbox

This toolbox is small in size and made of pliant, fashioning it a lightweight and easy-to-carry storage alternative. You can store hand tools in the bottom compartment and their fasteners in the extractable storage compartment. Because of this toolbox's small size up, it's best for the homeowner WHO only has a few tools that they need to carry from room to board when doing the occasional home maintenance task.

Key Features

Plastic cloth
Metal latch in the front
Handle on the top
Extractible compartment inside

What Customers Are Saying

Close to 1,000 customers reviewed this tool cabinet, giving it an average rating of 4.5 stars. 88 percent of these reviews are 4 or 5 stars. While customers were aware that this material is less lasting than composite or steel, they tranquil said that the plastic was hard and the metallic latches were heavy-obligation. However, several customers received the toolbox with a freestanding handle, and they couldn't figure stunned how to reattach it.

Our Experience

Biotechnology

This tool chest was the easiest one to lift and carry in this review. Because of its small size, it can only hold so many tools, making it whippersnapper to transmit careless of what you put in it.

Security

The united metal-looking door latch in the anterior of this toolbox is enough to keep the tools secure inside, even when the loge is dropped from a a couple of feet away the terra firma.

Organization

Similar to the DEWALT DWST17820 and DWST08204 toolboxes, this toolbox has only one extractible compartment at the top of the boxful. While this is less of an issue with this toolbox because it's so reefy and can only hold a few more tools below the compartment, it still agency you'll have to dig through with a mound of tools to find the script tool you want to use.

Durability

This product received the worst lastingness score in this review because information technology's made of plastic and doesn't take over an IP rating, meaning that dirt and water can easily get indoors. However, it performed healthier connected the brick test than we supposed. It sustained a crack crossways the top, but that crack didn't make the toolbox unusable.

Our Score

This toolbox conventional all of the possible points for ergonomics and security. However, it lost points for organization because it has only i compartment, and it ruined points for durability because of its plastic reincarnate.

Marking Breakdown

Measured	Grudge
Metric	Mark
Ergonomics	5/5
Security	5/5
Establishment	3/5
Durability	2.5/5
Overall score	3.9/5

Best Multi-Purpose: Stalwart Heavy-Duty Resonant Tool chest

This tool case from Stalwart can store a wide variety of tools. Its top boxful has compartments for small tools and fasteners, and its bottom box has an open space to hive away large tools. This tool case besides has 3 wheels for conveyance—one in the front and two in the back. You hindquarters pull information technology up onto the two back wheels or use all three wheels to bike it unmodulated crossways the found.

Key Features

Plastic textile
11.05 pounds
Cardinal toolboxes shapely on top of each other
Ii wheels in the back and one wheel in the front
Adjustable address in the back and a handle on the height
Two latches in the front and cardinal latches on the sides
Removable compartments inside both boxes
Three built-in compartments in the top box
Three hooks on the exterior for cords and other accessories

What Customers Are Saying

Just concluded 1,000 customers get reviewed this product on Amazon. It has an average rating of 4.2 stars, with 77% of customers giving it 4 or 5 stars.

Customers said this tool case did a great job of storing large equipment and their small accessories. Whol of the small compartments in the top box allowed for accessory storage, and the big open boxwood on the tail end allowed for tool storage. Some customers expressed their concerns about the quality of the cartesian product, specifically citing how the hinges on the lid of the top box broke if you stored too umteen tools inside.

Our Experience

Ergonomics

This toolbox can be easily wheeled on different types of flooring, including tile, practical, and carpet. However, we experienced or s difficulty when difficult to transport it in a car. Because of how tall this toolbox is, IT will tip over if you support information technology abreast a car seat operating theater in the trunk. You either have to lay it down or position IT on the floor where a passenger's feet would go when transporting it in a car.

Security

This is the only toolbox that lost points for its latching mechanism. When the product arrived, the latches on the top of the toolbox were already broken, so we couldn't secure the lid when wheeling the item just about. To boot, this product failed the drop test, as the lid flew open as soon as it hit the basis.

Administration

This toolbox has the most storage compartments out of each of the products in this reassessmen, with five in the lead loge and two in the bed. Three of the compartments in the top boxful were foster regulated into smaller sections to allow storage for small supplies.

Durability

While this toolbox is ready-made of plastic, which is inferior durable than steel and composite plant, and is vulnerable to weather conditions, it still withstood the brick examination with only a few kid scratches.

Our Score

This Sturdy toolbox mixed-up points in the ergonomics, organization, and durability categories, but this was chiefly because the product was poorly constructed.

Scoring Breakdown

Metric	Score
Metric	Score
Ergonomics	4.6/5
Security	2.5/5
Organization	5/5
Durability	3.5/5
Overall score	3.9/5

Purchasing Guide

Since each tool chest differs in terms of material, mobility, and storage quad, decide what you want out of yours earlier making a buy in. Here are some important factors to consider earlier buying a toolbox.

Storage Space

Toolboxes come in unusual sizes depending on the tools you're nerve-racking to hold. Little boxes, for example, are good for hand tools the likes of hammers and screwdrivers, while larger boxes are best for holding power tools comparable cordless drills and jigsaws.

Load Capacitance

Load capacity is how very much weight a toolbox derriere concord. Most manufacturers testament offer this list in the product description Beaver State proprietor's manual. In worldwide, expect asterid dicot family and steel toolboxes to obtain more weight than plastic ones.

Terms

The price of a toolbox ranges from $15 to over $100, depending on its size up and material. If you're looking for a unimportant, fictile toolbox, you'll pay fewer than if you'Re look for a heavy-responsibility steel or composite one.

Review articl Standards

We started our toolbox research by looking at the options available on Amazon, paying uncommon aid to Amazon superlatives like Amazon's Prize and #1 Bestseller. We also considered factors like-minded Choice shipping eligibility, the number of customer reviews for each product, and the average customer rating for each product.

We then narrowed our options by looking at factors specific to toolboxes, such as corporal, portability, storage compartments, and lockup mechanisms. After our research, we selected six products, which we ordered and tested using the metrics below.

Testing Prosody

To determine the best mathematical function for each toolbox and who would gain most from each point, we tested the products on ergonomics, security, organization, and enduringness.

Ergonomics

When looking at toolboxes, it's important to determine how easy it is to stockpile the box when it's full phase of the moon of the tools it was designed to hold. If you're doing a home improvement project and need to carry your tools around the home, you whitethorn want a toolbox that has a handle or wheels so that IT can easily be transported.

Security system

Your toolbox should have some sort of latching chemical mechanism so that it doesn't open and plunge unsuccessful your tools when you lift it during travel. A high-quality toolbox may even have a lock on it to prevent your tools from being stolen.

Arrangement

A toolbox with storage compartments or drawers allows you to organize your tools and well witness them. The alternative to this is a box with none organization where you have to dig through a mound of tools to find the one you want.

Enduringness

Traditionally, toolboxes make been made of either nerve operating theatre plastic. Steel boxes are more indestructible and last longer, while plastic toolboxes are typically more low-cost and weigh less, making transportation easier. Some newer toolboxes are made of complex—the assortment of cardinal or more materials makes these toolboxes straight-grained more durable than steel ones.

Another durability broker to consider is a toolbox's Ingress Protection Cipher. This code is old to learn how healthy mechanical casings protect against the elements, like rain and hail. The first digit represents a tool case's protection from solids, and the second digit represents its protective covering from liquids. You'll want a toolbox that has a valuation of IP65, IP66, IP67, or IP68—these codes refer to a toolbox that has final solid protection and some grade of liquid protection.

Examination Process

To test all tool cabinet, we performed a variety of tests that allowed us to score each product on ergonomics, security, organization, and durability.

Biotechnology

To test this factor, we started by transporting the toolboxes without tools in them. We tested wheeled toolboxes by moving them on hardwood and carpet and by lifting them in and out of a gondola. We time-tested handled toolboxes by carrying them ahead and drink down three flights of stairs and lifting them in and come out of the closet of a car. The toolboxes received a grade for each test on a scale of measurement from 0–5, and the 2 scores were averaged together.

After performing these tests, we added tools to the toolboxes and performed the same tests to find if the added weight had affected their ease of fare. Once more, their score for this was an average of the slews from both tests. Their final biotechnology score was an middling of the general score without tools inside and the overall score with tools inside.

Security

We confirmed that each toolbox had a latching system and ensured it didn't open while performing the ergonomics tests. We also held each weighed down toolbox five feet off the primer and dropped it to see if the latch became undone and any tools fell out.

Organization

We determined how many storehouse compartments and pouches all tool cabinet had. Toolboxes with at least five compartments received full points, while toolboxes that had fewer compartments lost points.

Strength

To test strength, our team first looked at the material the toolbox was ready-made of and its IP rating. We so performed a brick test to determine how the toolbox delayed against wear and tear. The brick test entailed dropping a brick on each box from five feet higher up the ground and noting if the box conventional any damage or remained relatively unscathed and still usable.

Scoring

To each one metric was scored out of five points, and the final score is an average of the metric scores.

Ergonomics

After our team members calculated the ergonomics scores, we awarded points as follows:

If a tool case received a 5, it received 5 points.
If a tool chest received a 4, it received 4 points.
If a toolbox received a 3, it received 3 points.
If a tool case received a 2, it received 2 points.
If a toolbox standard a 1, it received 1 point.

Security

A toolbox received 5 points if information technology didn't open during our biotechnology tests surgery our drop test, and the tools remained inside of the box. We gave a toolbox 2.5 points if IT agaze during the ergonomics or drop tests and the tools fell out.

Organization

Our squad awarded 5 points to the toolboxes that had five or much pouches operating theatre compartments, 4 points for toolboxes that had four pouches operating theatre compartments, and 3 points for toolboxes that had three pouches operating theater less.

Durability

Two points were assigned founded on the material used to conception the boxes. Complex boxes conventional 2 points, brand boxes received 1.5 points, and plastic boxes acceptable 1 point. We as wel awarded 1 point to a toolbox based along its IP rating. A box with a paygrad of IP65, IP66, IP67, or IP68 received the full stop, while a package with a paygrad lower than those codes received uncomplete a point.

The remaining two durability points were awarded based on the toolbox's execution during our brick essa. If the box was unscathed or slimly crumpled, it received 2 points. If the toolbox was seriously tatterdemalion but withal serviceable, it received 1 point. If the toolbox was mutilated past the point of utilise, it received 0 points.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is powder coating?

Pulverization coating is a spray-on plastic operating theater polymer that prevents rust on chromium steel steel. It's used along both toolboxes and tool chests and is preferred to regular paint because information technology's tougher and more affordable.

What is the manufacturer measurement when describing the toolbox in inches?

The list mentioned is the toolbox's length. However, this total can personify misleading because 20-edge boxes could have different depths and heights. We recommend looking the least bit three of the box's dimensions instead of just the one advertised by the manufacturer to get a inclusive understanding of the product's storage space.

What if my tool cabinet doesn't have compartments?

If your toolbox doesn't come with a tool organization system, you can always purchase one separately. You put up buy organizers for specific tools equal wrenches and pliers, or you rear end buy out general plastic organizers that will work for a variety of items.

To share feedback or take a inquiry about this article, send a note to our Reviews team up at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com .

Harbor Freight Five Drawer Vs Four Drawer Tool Cart

Source: https://www.thisoldhouse.com/storage-organization/21565112/best-toolbox